I can not participate in the poll, since my favorite stocks are Micarta. Ivory would be the most attractive, followed by an attractive wood. I still have some Pachmayr rubber stocks from the '80s, and they do function quite well.
Still, my favorite would be black line Micarta, followed by green canvas Micarta.
Depends on the gun and the mood I'm in. Right now my park'd 1911 wears rosewood, but I intend to get some pachmayr American Legend, Hogue wraparounds, some kind of alumagrips, and probably a faux ivory.